Miss Mel’s Bakery is a trusted bakery and cake shop in Lima, OH, bringing together fresh-baked flavor, beautifully crafted cakes, and a warm neighborhood feel that keeps customers coming back.
Known for quality, convenience, and a 5.00 rating from 125 reviews, this Lima bakery and cake shop is a go-to destination for celebration cakes, sweet treats, and baked goods made with care.
Whether you need a custom cake for a birthday, a special dessert for an event, or a delicious bakery stop for everyday indulgence, Miss Mel’s Bakery offers the kind of friendly service and standout taste that make every visit worthwhile.
For customers searching for a top-rated bakery and cake shop in Lima, OH, Miss Mel’s delivers a welcoming experience, dependable quality, and memorable baked creations that bring joy to every occasion.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Miss Mel's Bakery
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
Mel from Miss Mel’s Bakery went above and beyond to make our baby shower cookies special and unique! She was absolutely lovely to work with and made the planning processes easy and seamless. She exceeded all expectations from the flavor of the cookies and macarons to all of the tiny details she added to it. My mom requested bear shaped macarons and cookies for my baby shower. Mel did not disappoint. Not only were they adorable but the flavor of the cookies left everyone wanting more. Mel went above and beyond to make my mom’s request happen. She made sure to package all the cookies due to family members having certain allergies. She kept her updated with the whole process. I would recommend Miss Mel’s Bakery to anyone, and I can't wait to come up with another event to get those amazing macarons from Mel!
We ordered cookies for my son's memorial event. They were absolutely stunning! Everyone loved them. This place is a 12 out of 10! Highly recommend!
Top notch customer service and very accommodating. My son turned 21 and the highlight of my day was the picture of him and the cake. What a nice surprise ! Mel knows the personal touch and this mom out of state really appreciated it.
Mis Mel went above and beyond with my son's 2nd Birthday cake. It turned out amazing! She is easy to work with and reaches out with ideas that will work for your cake. Easy to contact and to talk to. This is my second time working with her and will definitely have more orders in the future!
I ordered macarons for a bridal shower. I told Miss Mel the theme and gave her complete creative freedom. She absolutely exceeded my expectations and they were even better than I could have imagined! If you need a sweet treat for any occasion, I HIGHLY recommend Miss Mel’s Bakery!!
I found this cookie idea on Pinterest and was determined to have them for my daughters’ birthday party. I reached out to Miss Mel and asked if she would be able to do it, she replied right away with a YES and all the info I needed! She was wonderful to work with and delivered the most perfect cookies! Highly recommend Miss Mel’s Bakery for all your custom cookie needs!
I definitely recommend Miss Mel's! I ordered custom macarons for my dad's retirement party and they were delicious and cute too. He loved them and they were a hit at the party (hence the late photo after a few had already been gobbled up). Miss Mel's was great to work with and also accommodating with pick-up.
Over the holidays, I had the good fortune of placing orders with Mel on 2 separate occasions & was extremely pleased by both experiences. First, I ordered her special Christmas pack of macarons, each with a different flavor & holiday design. They were packaged in an attractive way & conveniently wrapped, with instructions, including how to freeze prior to gift giving. The recipients were delighted. Next, I ordered 2 dozen sugar cookies with 3 custom designs for a post rehearsal party. I had already tasted the sugar cookie recipe (delish) & simply sent her the designs I wanted printed on the cookies. They were an exact match, & the bride & groom were thrilled with the personal touch. In both cases, I paid online & picked up the orders at her home. Very convenient! I highly recommend Mel’s gourmet baked goods & will order again in the future.
She made a smash cake, a larger cake, and cupcakes for my son’s first birthday party & it was a hit! She did an amazing job with the blippi theme and everything tasted amazing ! Highly recommend!
Mel created gorgeous cookies for my friend’s gender reveal party. She was great to work with and her services are easy to use for payment and scheduling pick up! I highly recommend her cookies, they are highly detailed and taste great!
Common questions about Miss Mel's Bakery
Miss Mel's Bakery is located at 2545 Sherwood Dr, Lima, OH 45805, United States, Lima, OH, United States.
You can reach Miss Mel's Bakery by calling +1 419-333-1767.
Miss Mel's Bakery has a rating of 5.0 out of 5 based on 125 customer reviews.
Miss Mel's Bakery features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park.
Miss Mel's Bakery features the following service options: Takeaway, Delivery, On-site services.
Miss Mel's Bakery features the following offerings: Coffee.
Miss Mel's Bakery features the following planning: Appointment required, Quick visit.
Miss Mel's Bakery features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
